Homesteading Forum banner
1 - 20 of 73 Posts

·
Formerly Kathleen in AR
Joined
·
1,050 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
If you could only have one "ideal" gun for your homestead, what would it be? And why?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,422 Posts
.22 rifle. The ammunition is cheap and plentiful. The gun is lightweight, and easy to use. This gun is common, and will serve most purposes very well.

Hopefully it will never be necessary for me to only have one gun, as there are uses for other types of guns as well. I have several types of guns, just as I have several types and sizes of screwdrivers.:cool:
 

·
AFKA ZealYouthGuy
Joined
·
11,454 Posts
Personally, I don't think you get a "one gun" ideal gun.

That said, a 12 gauge shot gun can bring down large game, small game, and is even decent for self defense. Sure you can't reach out and touch someone, but we're talking homesteads here and not zombie hordes.


I think if you had a .22 like the Ruger 10-22 and a good 12 gauge you would be all set.
 

·
Trainer of kids, dogs and horses...fears nothing
Joined
·
8,598 Posts
I think everyone should have at least two.
Everyone should have at the least a shotgun (12guage if only one) and a rifle, and I'd go just a smidge bigger than a .22

Were we to narrow it to just one, though, I'd go with a .243 rifle just because it's light, shells are readily available absolutely everywhere, and it'll bring down larger game easily.
 

·
In memoriam
Joined
·
79,016 Posts
If forced to have just one, I'd take the 22.

It can kill anything a shotgun can, and do it at longer distances, and cartridges are so small you could carry 1000+ of them easily.

Reality is , though, you should have a minimum of 4:
1 shotgun
1 22 cal
1 larger caliber rifle
1 large caliber handgun
 

·
AFKA ZealYouthGuy
Joined
·
11,454 Posts
Hey Erin,

That's difference I see more pronounced as you head west. You folks have all that open land and the .243 is effective for those longer shots on the big game. In the situation I think of (in the midwest/east) I think of the shotgun as being the primary game-getter, and the .22 is the primary lead slinger, small game, everything, cheap to fire and practice with gun.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
299 Posts
I'd say a shotgun too. You don't have to be the greatest shot to take small game and/or unwanted creepy crawlers. Taking a flying birds, snakes, etc with a 22 requires considerable more skill . If you want to hunt larger critters you can go with slugs. As long as you don't let an intruder too close to you a shotgun makes an excellent home defense gun too.
 

·
de oppresso liber
Joined
·
16,879 Posts
The first firearm almost anyone should buy and if you only have one it should be a shotgun, 12 ga unless you are just not physically able to handle it. FIY, if a small 12 y.o. girl can lean to fire one almost any one can.

The main reason is it is the most versatile weapons out there. Let's look at the reasons most homesteaders need firearms for.

#1 Gathering food

A 12 ga shotgun can be loaded so it can kill anything from quail to moose. With one gun you can fairly easily fill your meat freezer. While you can't take down critters at 300 yards with todays modern saboted slugs you can take deer 50 yards with a standard barrel and if you buy a second, rifled bbl you can double that range.


#2) Protecting your garden and animals from critters.

Its kinda hard to hit that 'possum, ****, weasel or dog that comes running out of the chicken house with a rifle of any caliber. And you have to be a good shot with a 22LR to kill that pesky deer that keeps eating the green beans you are planning on canning for the winter.


#3) Protecting you from critters.

Very few weapons have the raw stopping power of a shotgun. When its YOUR body on the line you want something which will stop that rabid dog and will stop it NOW. If you have to deal with two legged critters the big hole in the business end of the old 12ga has a very, very large intimidation factor, ask anyone who has been on the wrong end of one. So which would you rather have with you while you are waiting for the police to show up after you dial 911, a rifle or shotgun?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
181 Posts
If you were truly absolutely limited to ONE firearm... 12 or 20 gauge shotgun. Although, honestly, for 250-300, one could obtain new shotgun and bolt action .22 rifle, less if you don't mind used (which I don't...most of my firearms are older than my grandparents...)

Still, I would give priority to the shotgun...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
74 Posts
I know Savage used to make an over/under that had a .22 as the top barrel and a 20 ga. underneath, I wonder if they still make it? Haven't seen one in a long time so probably not. Maybe take a look around gun shops for a used one?

Also, I saw an ad a few weeks ago for a Rossi interchangeable-barrel gun that I think was a .22, .243, and a 20 gauge. That might be just the ticket.
 

·
Gimme a YAAAAY!
Joined
·
5,327 Posts
I'd say we use our over&under .22/.410 for most "homesteading" activities.
One gun that is both a rifle and a shotgun. Very handy.
 

·
Hired Hand
Joined
·
1,670 Posts
If I could only have one I'd pick a reliable, bolt action .22 LR with a scope for reasons already stated. Ammo is cheap...I just picked up a brick (500 rounds) for $14. Realistically, I'd also like to have a 12 ga shotgun to go along with that. Kind of like hammers...you won't want to use a sledge for driving tacks or a tack hammer for driving spikes.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
547 Posts
I fall into the you really need two group.
My choice would be a good .22. Ruger 10/22 comes to mind. A and shotgun, but I differ with most here. My choice would be in 20ga. Out to 50 or 60 yds the 20 is very reliable on a par with a 12ga. In home defense with buckshot there is no difference to speak of.One advantage is that a smaller person can use easily without the fear of the heavier recoil.
just my .02 worth.
Tom
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
I vote for 12 gauge pump shot gun, so i can get several shots off in sucession. I also have a 22 automatic rifle and a 38 pistol..Jay in N.C.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
66 Posts
If you could only have one, it would be a 12 or 20 gauge shotgun, just depending on which guage you prefer. If you could have two, add in a .22 rifle.
 

·
Just howling at the moon
Joined
·
6,586 Posts
For me it would have to be something like the .223 brushmaster
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
29 Posts
For a "one gun" scenario SunnyJim may have hit on the ideal which is a combo gun. The one he is referring to is the Savage 24 series. Many variations were made over the years with 12 and 20 gauge and .410 bore shotgun with the rifle half being .22, 22 mag, .222, .223, .357, .30-30 and 22 Hornet. The only downside is that these are single shot which is not good for home defense. Shotguns are amazingly versalite firearms and with slugs are capable of taking large game at closer ranges. In reference to seedspreader's comment, here in Appalachia the most common game getter would be one of the following: .243, .270, .30-30 or .30-06.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
161 Posts
Thompson/Center Encore.

But that's kinda cheating.
 
1 - 20 of 73 Posts
Top