Homesteading Forum banner

Has anybody ever tried this? (Linux on a thumb drive)

420 Views 10 Replies 6 Participants Last post by  NRA_guy
2
I know I can install Linux on my hard drive, but I just wondered if anybody has tried this.

Input device Circuit component Computer Finger Peripheral



After plugging the Xtra-PC® USB into your computer, the device quickly bypasses your old, clunky Mac or Windows operating system and replaces it with a lightning-fast and easy-to-use system powered by Linux. Just like Windows and Mac, Linux is an operating system. To put it simply, the operating system manages the communication between your software and your hardware.

Within minutes, your computer will run better than the day you bought it.
Gadget Communication Device Font Software Material property

Link

--------------------------------------------
See less See more
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
I haven't used that one, but I routinely use several Linux live systems in my work, from USB or CD/DVD. To be really useful as a desktop system, if you're ever going to want to save anything to disk (even settings, bookmarks, etc.), they have to be set up with some persistent storage space, about which this one doesn't mention anything.

You can get the same thing on Ebay for $10-$15, and with your choice of Linuxes; this one doesn't even mention what Linux they're using. Or you can do it yourself for the cost of a flash drive or blank DVD if you can follow a few simple instructions.

Aside from the exorbitant prices, I wouldn't buy this one just based on the first sentence on their website. Describing a Linux live USB as 'revolutionary' isn't very honest; bootable live systems have been common for 20 years, and most Linuxes have done it for most of that time.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
You can download a Ubuntu iso, for example, from Ubuntu and use some free software like BelnaEtcher and put the ISO on you own USB stick and you are ready to run. No need to buy something special to do the job. NOTE: You may need to change the system BIOS to boot from a USB drive. Other than that, it's pretty simple.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Yes, you can download a smaller linux on a flash drive, boot it from flash and run it from local memory without any needs to install it. There are some limitations as you only have the tools on the thumb drive.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Yes, you can download a smaller linux on a flash drive, boot it from flash and run it from local memory without any needs to install it. There are some limitations as you only have the tools on the thumb drive.
The current LTS edition of Ubuntu needs only 25Gb of drive space, that would easily fit on a usb stick. Would that be the best way to go, not really. If it were me and I wanted to have a removable OS on my system I would get an SSD and if available plug it into an external sata port. Hot swap 2.5" drive bays work well. I use them all the time for testing different OS versions, when I need a native hardware install and a VM will not do the job.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Thanks, folks. I mentioned it to my computer guru son at lunch today and he said, "Noooo. You can do it for free without buying that stuff."

And he basically told me the same thing y'all said.
Sorry I'm a month late, don't get on here very often.
Ventoy is a multi-boot loader. Install Ventoy to a USB then simply copy your ISOs to the primary folder. Set your BIOS or UEFI to boot from USB before checking the hard drive and you're set. Ventoy will start up and show you every ISO you've copied over. If you're wanting to test drive several distros or if you want to show several distros to someone who's interested in Linux, it's hard to beat this setup. The Ventoy installation is persistent. On mine I've got a few BASH scripts copied to the secondary folder. They're for adding some additional desktop security and some utilities I find useful for certain new installations.
The scripts check to make sure ufw is installed, then enable the firewall. They also offer to install Bleachbit, PortMaster, Privoxy, some of the webext packages such as Privacy Badger and Ublock Origin. I can set up a highly paranoid system for use in homeless shelters, halfway houses and domestic abuse shelters where personal privacy and security are top level needs for clients needing to contact lawyers, doctors, therapists and employment counselors.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Use a good quality thumb drive if thats what you want to use. Cheapies tend to be SLOW and not very reliable for booting an operating system.

Modern computers can be little more involved in getting computer to boot from external drive, usually secure boot has to be turned off in bios, and windows has to be FULLY shut down, not in hibernation. I think some like Ubuntu can even deal with secure boot. Be aware bigger distribution will boot slower and tends to run slower especially on older computer. But Ubuntu can be nice for a newbie as its windows-esque in its big brother attitude. Its based on Debian. Lubuntu is the fastest of the Ubuntu family on older computer, it uses LXQt desktop, its ok, liked it better when it used LXDE. Not officially Ubuntu family but derivative of Ubuntu is Bodhi, its smaller and slick looking. Frankly for Debian based, I like MX, I still daily use older version MX19, it is super stable and just never breaks. Or even straight Debian, though straight Debian assumes you have your big boy pants on and know what you are doing. There are unofficial community Debian "spins" with whichever desktop you want. LXDE is the lightest and fastest. For small fast distribution, Puppy is still around in several flavors and the originator of Puppy, though retired from actual Puppy development has an interesting experimental containerized system called EasyOS. I like EasyOS, just use Etcher or Rufus or dd to write it to thumb drive and you are done. Barry has a subforum on the Puppy forum for EasyOS and he has his own site too.


See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Thanks guys. (Wow! I need to study that new language to understand it. :) )

Reminds me of a handwritten sign I saw at a carnival coin toss game around 1962:
"If you don't understand how to play this game, ask and I will explain it. If you still don't understand how to play it, go play some other game."
Yea, think for booting from thumb drive, you will be happiest with either one of the Puppies or else EasyOS. The bigger distributions, its difficult to install it so it keeps settings, mostly designed to be alternative to dvd for installing the distribution in traditional way to internal hard drive.

Easy is a bit different but takes very little time to write it to thumb drive and boot it. I use the linux version of Etcher to write it to thumbdrive. Just stupid simple that way. Rufus is windows only, though might be able to run it in WINE. dd is commandline, and already included in every linux if you are comfortable with commandline. Puppy and EasyOS are designed to run from thumbdrive. I think Barry offers a version dd with gui frontend. Use whatever you are used to.

Oh and as handy as thumbdrives are to carry around, suggest it doesnt cost that much more to get a smaller SSD and use a usb adapter. Sometimes used/refurbished ones are actually cheaper on Ebay than a new thumbdrive. They are usually much faster and more robust. The usb adapter/conversion cable for them is cheap. I recommend at very minimum, getting a 32GB thumbdrive or SSD. Price larger ones too as sometimes just few dollars more will get you lot more capacity.

Yea if you want Ubuntu or one of larger distributions installed standard way, definitely recommend a SSD.
See less See more
Thanks. Good info.

I have a bare 2.5-inch SSD (and several 3-1/2 and 2-1/2-inch rotating hard drives) and several USB adapters.
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top