Homesteading Today

Homesteading Today (http://www.homesteadingtoday.com/)
-   Plant and Tree Identification (http://www.homesteadingtoday.com/plant-tree-identification/)
-   -   Winter greens ?? (http://www.homesteadingtoday.com/country-living-forums/plant-tree-identification/422043-winter-greens.html)

motdaugrnds 11/27/11 08:40 PM

Winter greens ??
 
I found this plant just this month growing abundantly in a partial shady, moist, fertil soil around our Asian Pear trees and a Comfrey plant. We have had frosty nights that does not affect it negatively. The plants are only about 3 inches tall, yet still a taproot can be found. Can anyone identify this? (The "Edible Wild Plants" book I have rules out wild mustard and sorrels.)

http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n...all_greens.jpg

http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n...allgreens1.jpg

http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n...allgreens2.jpg

Danaus29 11/27/11 11:30 PM

The leaves look a bit like dandelion. Does it smell like dandelion?

motdaugrnds 11/28/11 06:44 AM

I really don't know what dandelion smells like as we have had so few around here this year. Do dandelions sprout and grow during late fall/winter months?

TnTnTn 11/28/11 09:58 AM

Looks like some sort of brassica to me. The turnip green, rape, kale and other brassicas appear similar. TTT

annie.oaktree 11/28/11 12:35 PM

One way to see if its a dandelion would be to snap off a fresh leaf and see if any milky substance is in the stalk which is a telltale sign.

My first instinct was a young chard or a brassica like TnTnTn said.

motdaugrnds 11/28/11 04:25 PM

If there is milky substance in the stalk, does that mean it is or it isn't a dandelion?

We have no planted any turnips, rape, kale or any brassica in our garden. I have no idea where these came from.

We did have a lot of Dock, Plantain and Redroot Pigweed come up wild in the garden; but this doesn't look anything like those. We also had smartweed come up abundantly; but this is not that either.

TnTnTn 11/29/11 10:49 AM

There are a lot of 'wild' or volunteer brassica types around cultivated areas that persist for years. TTT

motdaugrnds 11/29/11 07:33 PM

ROFL Yep, TnTnTn, I'm learning that alright. :)

jwal10 11/29/11 08:58 PM

Have you ever seen a lot of yellow flowers around there in the spring? Could it be wild mustard. It will come up for years from seed....James

http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=...ed=0CDYQ9QEwAQ

http://www.pennilessparenting.com/20...aged-food.html

.

motdaugrnds 11/30/11 09:48 AM

Thanks James. I'll go over and look at those urls.

Vickie44 11/30/11 04:00 PM

Maybe watercress ?

Danaus29 11/30/11 07:18 PM

Yes, dandelion sprouts and grows in the fall. And they don't always have milky sap.

naturelover 11/30/11 08:28 PM

My vote is for dandelion. I have dandelion seedlings growing here now that look just like that. They won't develop the lobes until the leaves mature more.

Just pinch off a bit and taste it. If it's dandelion it should have a mildly bitter taste.

.

motdaugrnds 11/30/11 10:00 PM

I took some of the leaves and chewed them up. They had a mildy bitter taste and reminded me of turnips.

If this is indeed dandelions, I am truly blessed. I take a tablet for high blood pressure that depetes my potassium; and dandelion greens contain this mineral. :)

J.T.M. 11/30/11 11:48 PM

It looks like it may be dock...


http://www.gardenorganic.org.uk/orga.../weed.php?id=1

motdaugrnds 12/01/11 11:09 AM

I'm not ruling out dock as we have plenty of that on the place; however, these are not growing like our dock do.

J.T.M. 12/01/11 02:26 PM

Wait................... does'nt dock have a tap root...mmmmmmmmmm .

jwal10 12/04/11 10:25 PM

Mustard greens have a bitter taste but less than turnip greens, sort of peppery....James

jwal10 12/04/11 10:27 PM

Danelions have more cut leaf....James

http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=...Q9QEwAQ&dur=90

motdaugrnds 12/09/11 09:35 AM

I picked some yesterday, just pulled entire plant out of ground and cut off the root system. I washed them and added some tiny fresh tomatoes (cut in half). Then I mixed up some poppy seeds, black pepper, powdered mustard and a little sea salt with some Olive Oil and tossed the fresh greens/tomatoes in this. Spread some shreaded mixed cheese and some thinly chopped/sliced ham with some slices of purple onion. These greens gave this chef's salad one of the best tastes I've had in a salad. The slight tang was perfect!

Tiempo 12/09/11 03:46 PM

Looks like arugula to me, but I'm not sure as only grow the rustic variety that has deeper cut leaves.

Is it peppery and kind of vaguely peanutty?

motdaugrnds 12/10/11 08:39 AM

Tiempo, I would not describe the taste as "peanutty". It is slightly bitter with a sweet-like turnip taste to it.

City Bound 12/12/11 08:53 PM

it looks like chard to me. One year my chard went to seed and then I little chards popping up all around that looked lik ethe plant you found. Did you ever grow chard in your garden in the past?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:33 AM.