
10/26/04, 11:24 PM
|
 |
|
|
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Texas
Posts: 575
|
|
Here, here!! Bravo. (WHY folks want to suggest breeds that have NO natural breeding for the reasons they seek is beyond me. Guess that explains how so many end up in the pound! Glad this person is Researching for what they want.. a GP!! 
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ditzyblond
Over the years, I have had alot of different breeds of dogs. By far and away my favorite, and the one that is doing the best job of guarding my livestock is my 2 Great Pyranees, Chip and Cody. It is true that they must live out there and grow up with the animals you want them to guard, instead of having them living in your house with you. Mine have lived with the other animals since I brought them home. They guard the yard from visitors well, but they know their main place is out there with the stock. They are still pretty young but already know their business. They have no interest in chasing or harassing any of my poultry, goats, or horses. They do bark alot at night, but we have alot of coyotes out here. Knock on wood, I have lost nothing to them since Chip and Cody have gotten bigger. Nothing can come near here without them sounding the alarm and chasing off after it.
My other breeds of dogs, collie, lab, aussie, old english sheepdog, a few mutts, they have always chased everything. My poor horses couldnt move a muscle without my collie running over and barking at them for 20 minutes. He just wanted everything to stay put.
You cant discount the centuries of selective breeding for temperment and behavior qualities that has gone into some of these dogs. Training will only do so much to get rid of genetically ingrained behaviors you dont want and can be costly and time consuming although it can be done. But in the meantime, your livestock could be in danger from predators that the dog does not know to chase away or from the dog itself. Your best bet is to get a purebred dog who's breed has the desired qualites from a reputable breeder and training it will be a snap.
As for mixed breed dogs, I am all for adopting them if you simply wish for a family pet, but the in-bred behaviors in mixed dogs are basically hit and miss and if you want them for a specific job, its going to be hard to find one that is suitable. I have also found that once a dog discovers the fun of chasing and or killing other animals, it is extremely difficult, if not impossible to stop them. They will know it is wrong but they just won't be able to help themselves. And you will not ever be able to trust them again.
Traci
|
__________________
"TIMSHEL"
Spoiler ALERT: For those of you who've never read Steinbeck's "East of Eden".... timshel means "thou mayest".
|