I've been doing some trials with various LED bulbs in several applications in our home and shop. I am a fan of LED's and believe they have great potential but in the grand scheme of things they are still 'new technology', at least as far as home lighting goes. As such I've resisted the temptation to run around and replace every bulb in the house with an LED just to realize some possible energy savings. While energy savings is important, so is the quality/color of the light, longevity, fit in the fixture(s), and the directionality of the light beam.
That said, I've had it with the screw-in CFL's after yet another one blew out several nights ago well before it's rated lifespan. I've given them a fair shot and I've heard all the excuses - 'use a different manufacturer', 'your circuits are bad', 'use a different wattage', 'it's too cold for them to work correctly', 'don't handle them with your bare fingers', etc.
Some recent experience this week:
- Purchased one screw base Cree 9W/60W daylight bulb and one Cree 9.5W/60W warm white bulb and installed them in a 3 bulb ceiling fixture along with a standard 60w incandescent. This fixture has a semi-clear glass cover. The Cree warm white is very close to the incandescent in color although it has just a bit less light out the top of the bulb. The Cree seems to emit more of the light from just the center of the globe whereas the incandescent looks to have light evenly distributed throughout the globe. As such when looking at the two it gives the impression that the incandescent is putting out a bit more light but this of course is subjective.
Also noted that the shape and size of the Cree is much closer to the shape and size of the incandescent which means it should fit in more various fixtures. In addition, the Crees seems to distribute the light more evenly than some of the other screw-in LED's I've tried. Specifically, the Cree does a much better job of distributing at least some of the light out the sides and out the bottom of the globe. Other LED's I've tried have a much more directional beam that mostly goes out the top of the bulb.
I will be purchasing two more of the Cree warm white bulbs to put in this three bulb fixture and we will see how it goes over time. Total wattage for three incandescents is 180 and for three Crees is 28.5 so it should be good in the energy category anyway.
The Cree 9W/60W daylight is simply too stark and harsh, at least with this clear covered fixture. I'm going to put that daylight bulb in the white frosted ceiling fixture in the hall and see how it looks.
Also going to try one of the daylight bulbs in my old trouble-lights. I used to use the old style trouble-lights with a 60W rough service incandescent but the drawback is they got really hot, which was not pleasant when I brushed up against it when working in tight quarters. Or when I laid it down while working in the crawlspace and it melted the plastic vapor barrier. I then moved to using a tube fluorescent trouble-light which took care of the heat issue but the fluorescent trouble-light is physically larger than the screw-in bulb trouble-light and the fluorescent sometimes has trouble starting in cold weather. The Cree bulbs have some sort of rubber covering on the globe which helps with gripping the bulb. It will be interesting to see how the Cree Led holds up when the trouble-light gets dropped on the concrete floor.
My local HD has some pretty good pricing on the two Cree bulbs at the moment.
$6.97 for the daylight and $5.97 for the warm white. I think the sign said regular pricing was $13.
http://www.amazon.com/Cree-9-5-Watt-...=cree+led+bulb
http://www.amazon.com/Cree-9-Watt-Da...=cree+led+bulb
- Purchased two of these Feit Par38 20W-90W dimmable weatherproof indoor/outdoor bulbs from Costco. Costco has a coupon sale price through the end of this month for $12.39 regularly $19.99. Replaced two burnt out 90W halogen bulbs in a motion sensing fixture in our immediate backyard. There are some internet reports that the bulb will take on water if oriented in a certain way and exposed directly to rain. In this case the fixture is under the eaves so I'm not overly concerned with that.
These bulbs are performing better than I expected so far. The beam is a bit narrower than the halogens and the light color is definitely harsher than the halogens but not as bad as I had feared it would be. These lights are mostly for security and convenience. Given that I don't spend a great deal of time out in that part of the backyard after dark, the light color quality is not so much of a concern.
Some things to consider with this bulb is that the weight of the bulb is quite a bit more than a standard bulb and it may put a strain on the typical cheap flood light fixture over time. And as in my case with it being used on a motion sensing fixture the payback time in energy savings will take longer than it will with a bulb that is on all night.
http://www.amazon.com/Feit-Electric-...rds=feit+par38